On inheriting my mum's sentences, and watching them read as a machine's
21 comments
I'm trying to counter this by trying to read more fiction, but for every page that I read, I'm probably reading 50 pages or so of LLM output. So I think this is a battle I'm going to lose out on in the long term. And I can probably only delay the inevitable.
But yeah, I don't like beginning to lose or doubt my own writing voice one bit.
The whole dashes debacle never made any sense, because many people are aware if you press and hold the hyphen "button" on your mobile touchscreen, it presents you options with different lengths you can choose from. That it was ever used as a signifier of LLM-written text meant that it can only show a false positive. For the last 20 or so years, a lot of web designers and content creators were "trained" on Elements of Style and other "best practices" cookbooks. People knew when to use what type of dash through these sources, as it gave a bit more of an elegant look to the presentation.
how are you measuring length?
because tailwind is not mentioned until the very last paragraph, 1900 words into a 2000 word article. and it is talked about for 3 whole sentences.
Yeah that's your problem. I like my em dashes. You don't need to be ashamed of your style just because it got mainstream. Doesn't matter whether it's AI or a fashion fad. It's like liking a music band before it gets popular on tiktok.
You'll be judged for riding in your old Tesla car, because people may think you're a fan of modern Elon.
It may sound like a stretch, but I feel it's virtually the same thing — style.
It's not about shame, it's about your work being dismissed because it's an indicator that you didn't put any effort into it.
Although by the end, the article veers somewhat, and reads more like "I put a lot of effort into my writing, and just because I use AI also doesn't mean that I want to be lumped in with the people churning out AI slop". Which, okay, but that's not quite as noble a position as they seemed to start off with.
It now occurs to me, non-humorously, that’s what this person and many others are going through with AI: it’s a multi-year fuzz test of their sense of self, their methods for ideation and expression, and their ethical principles on attribution and intellectual property.
Read the full thread on Hacker News →
Related stories
- Sonnet 5.5 Doesn't Worry Anymore. It Also Doesn't Think Anyone's in Chargepersona.earthpilot.aiHacker News · 2 points · about 24 hours ago
- Hacker News · 3 points · 4 days ago
- Hacker News · 2 points · 11 days ago
- Models Watching Modelssouthbridge.aiHacker News · 1 points · 10 days ago
- U.S. Small Biz Can't Ship to the EU Anymoreglog.glennf.comHacker News · 4 points · 9 days ago
- Why Do We Need Human Mathematicians Anymore?poshenloh.comHacker News · 4 points · 10 days ago