The expanded form of a testimony I prepared for Congress.
58 comments
I spent the last 2 days building basic AI agents to automate some mundane supply chain workflows for a large company. Those seemingly boring workflows had bank statements, supplier IDs and other sensitive information.
For me it was all alarm bells, there is no way they can afford to give closed models access to this data. I was compelled to figure out an open model based solution for them, which made me realize that this is probably the only way for enterprises going forward.
So if you're running open models on AWS GPUs, you might as well run Claude (which AWS supports, and doesn't share any data with Anthropic).
Same with Azure/OpenAI.
I want to believe (pinky promises from terms of service don't count)
Ah... oh.
Well, it's a nice thought.
I guess it depends if we believe that or not.
I see the flaw in your clever plan...
They are literally segmenting the world into haves and have-nots, just like nuclear power. Thank god China is out there and constantly undermining them with their non-stop open weights model releases.
The best situation for us mere mortals is one where they struggle against each other endlessly without any hope of victory. The second either the US or China wins, it's pretty much over for us and unimaginable oppression will quickly follow.
However, I think geopolitics has also become a factor as the very existence of this article indicates.
Additionally, the big labs’ formulation of AI as a US-vs-China national security issue is very convenient for keeping those pesky regulations at bay, and for ensuring the AI financial bubble doesn’t pop before everyone can unload in an IPO first. Both of these offend my sense of fair play.
The Chinese labs aren’t just putting models out there, they’re publishing and sharing their research and innovation too. That’s just a better way of doing science and contributing to the development of the whole field.
Read the full thread on Hacker News →
Related stories
- The current balance of power in open modelsinterconnects.aiHacker News · 1 points · 9 days ago
- Ars Technica · 0 points · 13 days ago
- Hacker News · 1 points · 5 days ago
- Hacker News · 93 points · 11 days ago
- CommonGrid: The open source registry of the US power gridcommongrid.infoLobsters · -1 points · 5 days ago
- Hacker News · 375 points · 1 day ago